Sales “Funnels”

Sales Funnel Graphs

Sales funnel graphs are used to represent the development of sales leads into actual sales, or conversely the attrition of sales leads before they become actual sales. In the example below, A might represent web site visitors, B visitors who accessed the specific sales page for a product, C visitors who clicked the link to receive additional information, and D customers who finally purchased the product.

Example Sales Funnel

Sometimes these funnels are drawn tapering to a point, as above, and sometimes they taper to a small but nonzero width, as below.

Example Sales Funnel

I don’t like this kind of funnel chart. Sit back and I’ll tell you why.

Funnel – Bad Metaphor

Sales funnels are so named because of a superficial resemblance to the kind of funnel found in many kitchens or inverted on top of the Tin Man.

Tin Man

This is where the metaphor breaks down, for me at least. In my kitchen, everything that goes into the top of the funnel comes out the bottom. That’s the purpose of the funnel: to make it easier to pour liquids and small particulates into a small-mouthed container without spilling. A sales funnel shows how much is left at a certain point, that is, how much has not spilled out. They really should be called sales “sieves”.

Funnel – Bad Graphic

Even worse than the bad metaphor is the bad graphical behavior of a funnel chart. Funnels badly distort their data. Let’s examine this distortion with the idealized funnel below. Each colored layer of the funnel has the same value, that is, I’ve constrained it to work like the funnels in my kitchen: what goes in at the top comes out at the bottom. These funnels are usually drawn to make the height of each section proportional to its value, and the stack of areas starts at a small width at the bottom (zero width in this one) and widens to a maximum height at the top. What our eyes see is a much larger colored region at the top, but our eyes are fooled by the hugely distorted areas.

Idealized Sales Funnel

In this graph, I have divided each colored area into triangles as large as the single bottom purple triangle. Although each colored band represents the same value, each band uses a much larger amount of area (number of small triangles) to represent this value. By the time we get to the top band of the chart, we have used 7 times the area of the bottom band, for the same encoded value. This is a poor means of encoding data.

Deconstructed Idealized Sales Funnel

Funnel Chart: From Bad to Worse

The specific graphic that kicked off my current rant was brought to my attention by Adam Vero of blog.meteorit.co.uk in a comment under my recent post, Excel 3D Charts: Charts with No Value. He read about a Simple Chart Modification in Microsoft Dynamics CRM 2011 in a Microsoft blog, in which a “Chart Wizard” (said I sarcastically) was showing how to improve on the length-squared distortion in a regular 2D funnel by pimping it into a length-cubed distortion in a fancy faux-3D funnel.

Funnel Charts: From Bad to Worse

This is bad on so many levels.

A Better Representation of Sales Flow

When I talk about improving a chart, I don’t mean increasing the pseudo-dimensionality of the chart, or increasing the use of gratuitous graphical effects, or blinding the readers with pizzazz. I talk about improving the transfer of information. Thanks again to Adam Vero for starting this discussion.

We can correct for the massive area distortion in a funnel graph by cropping the sides of the funnel. Now the remaining stacked column chart has columns that have heights and areas which are proportional to their values.

Truncated Sales Funnel

Here is the simplified stacked column chart. A lot easier to interpret than the funnel.

Sales Stacked Column

We want to represent retention in each step of the sales process. Bar sizes can be compared more easily if the bars are arranged side-by-side with their bottom ends aligned. The side-by-side arrangement also gives a somewhat intuitive sense of how the sales steps proceed, since we westerners interpret the passage of time from left to right. This clustered (side-by-side) column chart better represents the sales progression than does the previous stacked chart.

Sales Clustered Column

We don’t need the different colors in a clustered chart, and we can place our labels right below the bars.

Sales Column Chart

If our data is tied to events that have occurred on or by specific dates, we can convert the bar chart into a timeline. For example, we mailed out invitations to sales prospects on January 15, a large fraction of these emailed us for information by March 15, a smaller fraction attended our June 30 sales webinar, and by November 22, we had made sales to an even smaller group.

Sales Time Line

Peltier Tech Chart Utility

Comments

  1. I agree that these are useless. Some time ago I was helping someone to build a funnel chart in SSRS. They can also be implemented so that the areas, not the height of each region represents the data. For those interested, have a look at (there is an example too):

    http://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/en-IN/sqlreportingservices/thread/d04e79bb-45ff-4d11-8a7c-8f63e20c2607

  2. I’d think it’d more useful, in terms of the sales process, to track the percent change in “lost” customers from one step to the next rather than numbers remaining along the way. You can quickly identify where the biggest opportunity for change is.

  3. Great work Jon! Taking junk and turning it into something meaningful is a lesson everyone needs to learn. You’re step-by-step improvements and explanations are fantastic.

  4. Not to be picky, but you criticise the funnel for it’s distortion, right?
    The line you propose implies linear events and data which you simply don’t have. You don’t know the value for 1st of October but still you present it on the Y-axis.

  5. If a chart has discrete points plotted at specific values, and these points are connected by lines, it is a bit obtuse to assume any point along these lines which is not specifically marked, constitutes an actual (i.e., measured) data point.

  6. I think funnel chart is quite useless, but sometimes might be used in Power Point presenations

  7. Best -
    Using something in PowerPoint doesn’t make something less useless, unless your purpose is to elicit lots of ooh and aahs.

Subscribe without commenting

Write a Comment

I welcome comments from my readers. If you have an opinion on this post, if you have a question, or if there is anything to add, I want to hear from you. Whether you agree or disagree, please join the discussion. If you want to include an image in your comment, post it on your own site or on one of the many free image sharing sites, and include a link in your comment. I'll download your image and insert the necessary html to display the image inline.

Subscribe without commenting

Peltier Tech Chart Utility

 

Create Excel dashboards quickly with Plug-N-Play reports.

 

Site by: Dawud Miracle, Business Coach & WordPress Websites